Commentators as diverse as Ben WittesKevin Ks and Jennifer Rubin have tried to understand NSA rules violations in recent days in part by attempting to compare the number of violations to the overall number of queries, as if the percentage of errors is a useful metric to use.
The NSA itself is encouraging the same analytic framework:. In a conference call with reporters Friday, NSA Compliance Director John DeLong repeatedly said that the agency takes compliance seriously and that the audit's existence proved that. The mistakes are in the "parts-per-million or parts-per-billion range," he said.
I Am Wanting Swinger Couples Nsa is it really that hard
For purposes of this article, Nsa is it really that hard set aside the incompleteness of the recent report on NSA rule-breakingand the certainty that there are many more incidents of rule-breaking that we know nothing thah.
Let's also assume, for the sake of argument, that the NSA has yet to commit any "abuses," and discuss their surveillance generally, rather than just the phone dragnet.
What I want to focus on is the strangeness of comparing the number of NSA queries to Nea of violations -- as if a low percentage of violations is enough to reassure us about NSA behavior. According to the Washington Postsome NSA violations involve individuals whose cell phones are were surveilled legally when they were overseas, but who enter the U.
No one's better at hacking than the NSA. And now one of its powerful tools is available to everyone for free. “There’s really no downside” to releasing Ghidra. Why It's So Hard to. But setting aside lopsided poll numbers and imagining what a President Trump might do with the NSA raises the broader question of how tyrant-proof the agency really is: whether its vast. Here's How To Make It Really Hard For The NSA To Listen To Your Calls. There's no way to completely protect your phone calls from the government. But you can get close. New information about the NSA's spy program will continue to be released. Based on what we know so far, here are your options, listed from most to least effective.
There is information we don't have about these violations, and it's easy to Nsa is it really that hard hzrd the complicated, fragmentary information that we do have, but as best I can tell, one "violation" in this case would seem to mean that a single individual was affected.
By way of contrast, consider another sort of violation:.
But setting aside lopsided poll numbers and imagining what a President Trump might do with the NSA raises the broader question of how tyrant-proof the agency really is: whether its vast. The NSA’s interest in cryptocurrency is “bad news for privacy, because it means that in addition to the really hard problem of making the actual transactions private you also have to make. A detailed snapshot of what's known about the NSA surveillance programs. ProPublica; Electionland Although passive surveillance is often hard to detect, How the Rich Really Play, “Who.
In one instance, the NSA decided that it need not report the unintended surveillance of Americans. A notable example in was the interception of a "large number" of calls placed from Washington when a programming error confused the U.
That error also counts as one violation. But it seems to have affected thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of people in the U.
Nsa is it really that hard
Now consider a hypothetical. Say that the NSA carried out 1, queries in a year, and the only violation involved a foreigner who brought his cell phone over from China.
Now say that they carried out 5, queries per year, and the only violation affected most residents of Washington, D.
But you wouldn't know it from the "queries to violations" ratio. Now tuat a non-accidental violation.Hot Guy Needs Browning Illinois Hook Up Free Sex Women Montgomery
Say that an NSA analyst queries the surveillance agency's data in service of playing a joke on his best friend, or stalking his ex-wife, or blackmailing a U. The violation that resulted would vary in seriousness depending on which one it was, but any of them would be alarming.
So our analyst goes ahead and stalks his ex, committing one violation. And then he spends the rest of the month making legitimate queries. Does our notion of how alarming or serious his transgression was depend at all on whether the rest Lumen sex webcam his month involves 50 or 50, legitimate queries?
Hypothetical examples can only take us so far.
But it seems obvious to me that the relevant metric isn't the percentage of violations committed, whether mild or serious, accidental or intentional. As the Washington Post stated, "There is no reliable way to calculate from the number of recorded compliance issues how many Americans have had their communications improperly collected, stored or distributed by the NSA.Married Ladies Want Real Sex Port Allen
And I've yet to hear a plausible explanation for why it would unduly endanger national security to make that information public. But I am inclined to think it would reflect poorly on the NSA.
The official website for NSA -- the National Security Agency National Security Agency/Central Security Service (NSA/CSS). NSA leads the U.S. Government in cryptology that encompasses both signals intelligence (SIGINT) and information assurance (now referred to as cybersecurity) products and services, and enables computer network operations (CNO). Can the NSA open an encrypted VeraCrypt volume? Update Cancel. Answer Wiki. 6 Answers. Bill Brassfield, RSA bit, AES, then no one’s encrypted hard drive data is safe, regardless of how strong the encryption software is, and how well-chosen the password/passphrase is. Was TrueCrypt really broken, or is it a cover for NSA and a. Jul 07, · The CIA, DIA and NSA are all different, trust me dont get in to this it's really hard to break in to. You need the best qualifcation, deegree in Law Enforcement, you acutally need to be the best to join, you need to bring bonuses you haft to write more than Status: Resolved.
Doesn't analyzing what little information we do have by comparing NSA queries to violations create a perverse incentive? Say the agency's director, General Keith Alexander, finds out that violations have doubled in the month of September compared to last year.
So he calls up a computer whiz in his employ, orders him to have the machines carry out 10 million automated queries in North Korea, and suddenly the Iw can proudly report that its September violation to query ratio is the lowest ever. Am I missing something? Or does queries-to-violations tell us very little about how worried we should be?
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters theatlantic. By way of contrast, consider another sort of violation: Conor Friedersdorf is a California-based staff writer at The Atlantic, where he focuses on politics and national affairs.Lonely Housewives Looking Sex Howell
He is the founding editor of The Best of Journalisma newsletter devoted to exceptional nonfiction. Twitter Email.